I realised something uncomfortable about workplace wellbeing.

The other day I was in a meeting with a leadership team talking about employee wellbeing.

They were doing many of the right things. They had mental health benefits. An employee assistance programme. Wellbeing workshops during the year. Even a dedicated wellbeing page on the intranet.

On paper, the company had a solid mental health strategy.

And yet, when we started talking about how employees were actually coping with pressure right now, and when i asked why do they think this is the case, most of the leaders in the room weren’t entirely sure. and something became obvious very quickly.

it wasnt the lack of care, quite the opposite, they clearly did.

But there was a quiet (big) gap between the support the organisation believed it was providing and what employees were actually experiencing day to day and also what they needed.  And it made me realise something that I’ve now seen in dozens of organisations. Many workplace mental health strategies exist perfectly well on paper. But employees rarely experience them in the moments where they actually need support.

Stress is a silent hum

If you watch how stress shows up at work, it almost never looks dramatic. It’s rarely someone announcing they are overwhelmed or walking into HR asking for help. It’s never an announcement or a dramatic crash out.

Most of the time it’s much quieter than that.

Someone who used to be sharp in meetings suddenly feels mentally foggy. A manager who normally handles pressure well finds themselves snapping at small things. A high-performing employee starts procrastinating on tasks they used to complete easily.

On the surface, nothing looks “wrong”. But internally, the brain is often dealing with cognitive overload, uncertainty, emotional fatigue, or sustained pressure. And people tend to manage these moments privately.

They scroll their phone. They delay decisions. They pace around. They try to power through the day. They have heavier sighs. They driff off during meetings.

Very few people think, “This is the moment I should go find the wellbeing solution or ask my HR for support.”

And this is  exactly where many workplace wellbeing strategies quietly miss the mark. The issues I have realised is that most wellbeing policies are designed around organisational events — workshops, awareness campaigns, benefits packages, EAP and the infamous ‘ open door policy. But stress doesn’t show up according to the company calendar.

Stress rarely announces itself.

It appears in the middle of a difficult project. In weeks where the news cycle feels heavy. In moments where someone is trying to focus but their mind keeps drifting. Sometimes it’s in the pause before someone walks into the office. Or in the dread that creeps in when the Monday alarm goes off. Other times it looks like impatience, with deadlines, with colleagues, with teams that suddenly feel harder to manage.

These are the small signals most organisations miss. And when support systems are far removed from those everyday moments, employees often stop seeing them as something meant for them.The strategy exists somewhere in the organisation. But it doesn’t feel present in their working life.

There’s another side to this that I think about often

Leadership teams genuinely want to help their people. Most of them really do. But many of them are trying to do it without visibility into what their employees are actually experiencing.

They know how many people attended a workshop. They know the company offers mental health benefits. But they rarely know when anxiety is quietly rising inside a team. Or when cognitive overload is affecting how people work and make decisions. Or when employees are slowly moving from healthy pressure into burnout territory. By the time those signals become visible, the damage has usually been building for months.

A Design Thinking Issue

I don’t think organisations have a motivation problem when it comes to wellbeing.

I think they have a design problem.

The systems we’ve built around workplace mental health were never designed around how humans actually experience stress. They were designed around programmes and the off chance someone needs extra support. And programmes are visible to organisations but often (more often than not) invisible to the people they are meant to support.

The companies that are beginning to approach this differently are starting with a much simpler question:

What does support actually look like in the everyday moments where work becomes mentally difficult? Not during awareness month. Not in a scheduled training. But in the ordinary Tuesday afternoon where someone’s brain feels overloaded and they’re trying to push through.

When organisations begin designing support around those moments, something shifts. Wellbeing stops being a policy or a perk. It becomes something employees can actually feel.

And the more I work with companies on this, the more I realise something simple.

Most organisations don’t lack good intentions.

They just don’t realise how invisible their support systems have become.

‍